If it was good enough for Terri Schiavo

Thu, December 14, 2006


Living in the Washington, D.C. area, news outlets are abuzz with the story about Democratic South Dakota Senator Tim Johnson having a possible stroke and being in critical condition after brain surgery.

The buzz isn’t so much for his health per se, but with the possible impact on the Senate if he can’t serve, given the slim 51/49 majority the Dems won in November.

If, God forbid, Senator Johnson does not survive, South Dakota’s VERY Republican governor would be permitted to appoint Johnson’s successor — can we guess which party that person would be from?

But here’s the rub. There is apparently no protocol for what to do if Johnson survives, but is incapacitated. If Johnson is coherent but ill, he could resign. But if he is in a coma or otherwise mentally hampered from what people are assuming was a stroke (and subsequent brain surgery), and he can’t resign himself, there is no procedure to remove him.

You can bet all the money in your Christmas club account that there are at least a few GOP vultures who will press hard to get that seat to turn red from blue if the Senator survives but can’t serve, notwithstanding all the Republican talk since November 7 about bipartisan cooperation and working together for the good of the country.

For lawmakers who are potentially hatching such a plan, I have two words – Terri Schiavo.

Remember how you said that, even though Schiavo had been in a persistent vegetative state for over a decade, that you were convinced she had brain function? That she was able to see and hear and was aware of her surroundings? That she expressed emotion?

If Senator Johnson survives, but is severely incapacitated, then I say the same rules should apply to him.

That way, there’s no need to find a way to get him out of his hard-won Senate slot, and we can spend our energy hoping and praying for the Senator’s speedy recovery, not for the transfer of his seat.

So there you have it, Republicans — my holiday gift to you is that there’s no need to spend the next couple of weeks worrying about how to turn one man’s tragedy into a GOP power-grab.

Be Sociable, Share!

Related Posts:

8 Responses to “If it was good enough for Terri Schiavo”

  1. Johnny Says:

    Also: Strom Thurmon

  2. Kelley Says:

    So the powers of twisted Republican logic can be used for Good. I like your thinking, PunditMom!

  3. Mamacita Says:

    This is a great GOTCHA! Good job!

  4. Lawyer Mama Says:

    Mwaaahhhaaaaa (evil laughter). What goes around comes around!

  5. Moobs Says:

    I like the sound of this! (Always assuming of course that it is consistent with the position you adopted on Ms Schiavo at the time because our obligation is never to cede the moral high ground.)

  6. Gunfighter Says:

    Well, here is hoping for an unimpaired (or at least minimally impaired) recovery for Senator Johnson.

  7. Mom101 Says:


  8. Beonda Pale Says:

    Apparently, you don’t find this kind of political calculation the slightest bit ghoulish do you mom?

Leave a Reply