Mothers of Intention — Bea Arthur Was Much More Than Maude

Mon, April 27, 2009

Mothers of Intention


Welcome to this week’s edition of Mothers of Intention, PunditMom’s weekly feature on what other political moms are writing about around the blogosphere. This week, my friend Gloria Feldt has given me permission to cross-post her wonderful essay on the death of actress Bea Arthur, from her blog Powered Women. I loved this post because it reminded me that mothers and politics are everywhere, even on sitcoms.

Bea Arthur died this weekend at age 86.

She was a Tony-winning stage actress when Norman Leaw saw her and tapped her for a guest role in his famous “All in the Family” series, where she played Edith Bunker’s mouthy liberal cousin Maude who was always at odds with Edith’s conservative husband Archie. “Maude” soon became a sitcom of its own, and Arthur’s character continued taking on the significant social and political issues of the day — speaking up about all those subjects we were warned against bringing up in polite company, from sex and infidelity to politics and activism to death and depression.

It was the mid-1970′s at the height of second wave feminism, and if ever there were proof that feminists have a sense of humor, it was Maude’s way of playing even the most serious of subjects for laughs.

In this classic exchange between Maude and her husband Walter, who arrives home to find Maude distraught, the show dealt with abortion — a first on a major sitcom to do so forthrightly.

Walter: Maude, did you wreck the car again?

Maude: Did you hear that, everybody? DID YOU HEAR THAT? Not “Maude, are you sick?” Or “Maude, are you unhappy?” Or even, “Maude, are you pregnant?” No, “Maude, did you wreck the car again?”

Walter: You’re right, darling. You’re absolutely right. I’m sorry. So tell me, are you sick?

Maude: No.

Walter: Are you unhappy?

Maude: No.

Walter: Are you pregnant?

Maude: Yes.

They go through all aspects of the decision process. Maude, already a grandmother in her late 40′s, decides she should not go through with the pregnancy and has an abortion. Watch the video to see how her daughter speaks of abortion as it should be:

It was a little slice of realism rarely seen today, when the option of abortion is so often pushed again into the virtual back room and rarely mentioned in pop culture. The movie “Knocked Up,” for example, uses the euphemism “rhymes with smashmortion” rather than mention this — the most common woman’s surgical procedure — by name. And soap operas are famous for those well-timed miscarriages that avoid the sticky subject of real women making reproductive choices, while leaving the full drama of mistimed pregnancies available to their script lines.

After “Maude, Arthur had the chance to open up for public discussion yet one more previously off-limits topic: aging, especially the issues women face aging in a youth-oriented culture. She played Dorothy on “The Golden Girls,” the NBC comedy hit that ran from 1985-92. The show explored the lives of three older women sharing a household in Miama with Dorothy’s widowed mother, Sophia (played by Estelle Getty). Besides Arthur’s character, there was also Betty White playing the ditsy Rose and Rue McClanahan as the sexy senior, Blanche.

Arthur won Emmys for both “Maude” and “Golden Girls.” She was inducted into the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences Hallf of Fame in 2008, an honor well-deserved for her lifetime of extraoredinary work.

But personally, I am most grateful to Bea Arthur (and of course to Norman Lear and everyone associated with “Maude”) for bringing the reality of unintended pregnancy and abortion out of the back room and into the real human story where it belongs.

May she rest in peace and her memory be a blessing to all of us.

Thank you Gloria for sharing this for this week’s Mothers of Intention!



Be Sociable, Share!

Related Posts:

, , , ,

One Response to “Mothers of Intention — Bea Arthur Was Much More Than Maude”

  1. anniegirl1138 Says:

    I remember watching Maude. Despite my parents extreme conservatism, they let us watch Mauda and All in the Family. My dad railed against the abortion shows. Staunch right to lifer, he pretty much left my youngest sister no other option than teenage motherhood when she got pregnant at 16 – a decision I think he regretted years later when it was obvious to him what we had tried to point out to him at the time which was that my little sister should never have had kids at all.

    I had one pregnancy scare at 43 which was ironic because I had friends my age and a bit older who were actively pursuing pregnancy. We firmly closed the down on any more pregnancies after that, but I know I wouldn’t have gone through with having another baby had I been pregnant. I don’t buy into 40 is the new 30. It’s forty. Period. We treat pregnancy as close to an illness in all respects until the talk of preventing or terminating comes up it seems.

    I think we have gone leaps backward from the 1970′s as far as dealing with some of our “issues” as women goes.

    And just as an aside, why is life “issue” laden where women are concerned and simply “life” where men are concerned?


Leave a Reply