Paul Ryan for Vice President: Where’s the Sarah Palin Treatment?

Image via ryanforcongress2008

What do new GOP VP candidate Paul Ryan and former GOP VP candidate Sarah Palin have in common?

They’re both the parents of young, school-aged children. Ryan’s children — ages seven, eight and nine — are in that childhood sweet spot. They’re just old enough not to need attention every moment of the day, but there’s plenty of carpooling, after-school activities and homework to be done that means parents don’t get to sit down until after the kids are asleep — if they’re lucky.

Parenting in the 21st century is a full on, tag team sport. Except that for some reason, we still live in an age where mothers are still expected to be ones to carry the load, while dads (I know there are exceptions) chip in less frequently.

The not-so-funny thing is this — the media outcry over “who’s going to take care of the kids” was deafening when Palin accepted John McCain’s invitation to join him on the 2008 Republican ticket. I have yet to hear anyone ask Congressman Ryan how he can possibly hold up his fatherly duties to his three elementary school-aged children while doing his job as a Wisconsin representative AND campaigning across America as the person Mitt Romney hopes can save his presidential campaign.

Of course, I know some people will say, “Well he has a stay-at-home wife and Palin’s husband worked outside the home for a living.” Except that’s not really the issue. I explored this ongoing double-standard in the chapter of my book, Mothers of Intention, entitled “Who’s Taking Care of the Kids?”

As I remarked in that chapter — “We’re a country with some serious mother issues.”  We still are. Those issues haven’t gone away and, sadly, they probably won’t in my lifetime. It’s not just a conundrum about how modern motherhood is played out in the political realm — there are plenty of other media portraits of motherhood responsible for the ongoing belief that if you’re a woman with small children, you’re the one who must shoulder all the responsibility for your kids’ upbringing, regardless of whether you also have what George Clooney called in the movie Intolerable Cruelties, a “square” job.

Regardless of who is bringing home a paycheck, we continue to collectively obsess with “having it all” and work/life balance and who is or is not a “working mother.”  These so-called debates refuse to vanish and will continue to keep our attention.as long as a June Cleaver version of motherhood is stuck in our heads.

Whether you agree with the conservative politics of wunderkind Ryan or uber-mom Palin or not, one thing I would love to see change is the assumption that dads of small kids get a pass when it comes to the discussion of taking care of families. Or if they continue to get a pass, then mothers of small children who run for office (or hold high level power jobs like Marissa Mayer) will get a pass, as well. Can we take our collective judgment about who should be taking care of the kids and refocus the conversation on these two things — (1) how can we change policies so that mothers and fathers alike can take part in the obligations of child-rearing, and (2) can we all agree that it’s time to quit beating up on the mothers of America when it comes to this wide-ranging, “all-having” conversation?

Be Sociable, Share!

Related Posts:

, , , , ,

5 Responses to “Paul Ryan for Vice President: Where’s the Sarah Palin Treatment?”

  1. Dennis McDonald Says:

    I do not remember any of this with Palin. All I remember were comments about how unqualified she was for the job.

  2. deb Says:

    oh i remember it–esp. because her youngest has Downs. But even if one of Ryan’s kids had Downs, I doubt anyone would ask him if his time wouldn’t be better spent at home helping his wife shuffle three kids.

    One thing I think Anne-Marie Slaughter’s Atlantic article showed us is just how much a family sacrifices when one parent has a high-powered job that requires round the clock attention. It’s accepted when men ask families to make these sacrifices but it’s not when women do. As a consequence, no woman before Slaughter has dared to complain about the pressures publically. Instead, executive women have claimed they can “do it all” to show that their family doesn’t suffer for their job. We need to accept that yes, families make sacrifices when mom works round the clock, but guess what, it’s no different (better) when dad works round the clock. If we don’t like that, then as a culture, we need to make executive work more family friendly for both men and women.

    sorry – i didn’t mean to get on my soapbox! i guess my short answer is I agree – if we want to ask Palin about her family, then we need to ask Ryan too.

  3. Debbie Owensby Moore Says:

    It would be a step in the right direction if we just stop commenting on a woman’s clothes. Hillary Clinton was asked just recently what designers is prefers. Hats off to Secretary Clinton for asking the interviewer if she would ask that question to a man. We still have a long way to go.

  4. Bridget Says:

    I remember it. I also remember Hillary and Obama being very vocal about it being inappropriate!!!! And it was…..inappropriate and ridiculousness.

  5. chey Says:

    hi go mitt romney


Leave a Reply